National Security News

Reporting the facts on national security

National Security News

Hamas Israel

Hostage Deal ‘Close’ but Tensions Persist Amid Progress in Talks and Gal Hirsch’s Troubled Stint

In the midst of escalating tensions and a prolonged hostage crisis, recent developments in negotiations have brought both hope and dismay.

Reports from the U.S. and Qatar hint at a potential breakthrough in releasing hostages, saying that a deal is “closet than ever”, yet the situation remains tense, marked by frustration and controversy.

Hostage deal very “close”: Recent statements by Ismail Haniyeh, the chief of Hamas, suggested progress.

  • Haniyeh posted on Telegram that they are “”close to reaching a truce agreement” with Israel, signalling a glimmer of hope.
  • “The movement delivered its response to the brothers in Qatar and the mediators, and we are close to reaching a truce agreement,” he added.
  • National Security Council spokesperson John Kirby said that negotiators are “getting close to the end.”
  • Israel is yet to comment, although Netanyahu

However, this positive momentum has been clouded by ongoing frustrations among hostage families, demanding answers and action from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

Thousands joined families of hostages in a 5-day march to Netanyahu’s office in Jerusalem (Source: Getty Images)

Tensions escalate: On Monday, families walked out of a meeting with the war cabinet, expressing disappointment over what they perceived as conflicting priorities.

  • Families expressing disappointment at Israeli government at the fact that rescuing the hostages and destroying Hamas are equally important.
  • Some members of the Israeli parliament faced backlash for proposing stringent measures, such as imposing the death penalty on convicted terrorists, which families argued will make situation worse for loved ones.
  • Family members told them, “Stop killing Arabs” and focus on bringing back their family members, “Talk Life, Not Death” others chimed in.
  • One far-right lawmaker, Almog Cohen, fought back at the families, saying “You have no monopoly over pain. We have also buried more than 50 friends.”
Relatives of hostages at the Knesset National Security Committee hearing on 20 November. (Source: The Times of Israel: Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

Amid these complexities, Gal Hirsch, appointed by Netanyahu to lead hostage negotiations, finds himself under intense scrutiny and controversy. Despite his background as a former senior IDF officer, questions linger about his suitability for this critical role.

A Controversial Appointment: Handpicked by Netanyahu in the aftermath of a Hamas attack, Hirsch, a former senior officer in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), was expected to play a pivotal role in negotiating the release of Israeli hostages.

  • Hirsch earned accolades for his leadership during the 2006 Lebanon War, commanding the Galilee Division.
  • His resignation, stemming from the handling of the abduction of two Israeli soldiers on the eve of the conflict, triggered a damning report that prompted his departure.

Further complications arose as he was indicted for tax evasion totalling $1.9m, for allegedly failing to report profits on his operations in his defence company in Georgia, Defensive Shield.

  • Later his nomination to lead the police force in 2015 was withdrawn, adding to the cloud of scepticism surrounding his career.
Hirsch took to X to justify his efforts.

Despite appearing in a photo op with initially released hostages, Judith and Natalie Raanan, clad in a bulletproof vest and holding their hands, giving the impression of a rescue he wasn’t substantially involved in, questions about his capabilities persist.

Critics and families of hostages have called for Hirsch’s resignation, citing perceived ineffectiveness in securing the release of their loved ones due to his minimal involvement and lack of experience in hostage negotiations.

In parallel developments: The U.S. is working on building an international coalition to deter hostage-taking.

  • This collaborative effort seeks to unite democratic nations in preventing authoritarian regimes from wrongfully detaining their citizens abroad.
  • Roger Carstens the special presidential envoy for hostage affairs revealed that Secretary of State Antony Blinken tasked him with creating a collaborative effort resembling NATO’s Article 5.
  • This would encourage nations to collaborate when their citizens are taken hostage.
Val Dockrell is a London-based Senior Investigator and Open Source Intelligence (“OSINT”) specialist who has led in-depth investigations in multiple jurisdictions around the world. She also speaks several languages and is a member of the Fraud Women’s Network. Her X (formerly Twitter) handle is @ValDockrell.